J. Byron Wyndham and Associates, Attorneys at LawPhoto of office location
Blue Ridge Office  2460 East First St. Suite B-6, Blue Ridge, GA 30513  706.258.6222  (fax) 706.258.6277



Home

Contact Us

Library

Calculators

Links to
Real Estate
Professionals

 

 
   Cabin Rentals
   Coming Soon!

 


 

 

 


Return to Library of Legal Notes

Who gets the Earnest Money?

DISCUSSION:  Matt’s realtor is negotiating a contract for the sale of Matt’s property to Diane. The contract has the right price and lists no contingencies. Matt questions his agent specifically about whether Diane needs to sell her home in order to buy Matt’s home, and the agent points to the first page of the contract where the buyer has indicated that there is NOT real estate to be sold. The contract is executed and Diane begins the loan approval process. Three weeks before closing, Matt is contacted by his agent and told that Diane is "having trouble" with her loan because she hasn’t sold her property. One week before closing, Matt is told that Diane has not been approved for the loan and cannot close. Matt receives a copy of the rejection letter from the mortgage company, in which it states, "Since you have been unable to sell your house, there are insufficient funds for the down payment." The closing is canceled, and Diane demands the return of her earnest money. Matt refuses, pointing out that the contract clearly stated that there were no contingencies. Diane threatens suit, claiming that the contract failed because the loan was denied, not because she didn’t sell her home, and that Matt had been told three weeks before closing that she couldn’t sell her home.

QUESTION: Who is entitled to the earnest money?

ANSWER: Matt is entitled to the earnest money. The standard GAR contract requires the buyer to initial a statement that he/she either "DOES or DOES NOT HAVE REAL ESTATE TO SELL" in order to buy the property. The contract further states that if "DOES NOT" is selected, loan denial will not be grounds for refund of earnest money in case the property fails to sell. Contradictory verbal statements made by the buyer prior to loan approval have no impact and do not supersede the written contract.

 



              Blue Ridge Office  2460 East First St. Suite B-6, Blue Ridge, GA 30513  706.258.6222  (fax) 706.258.6277
                                                                  Email: jbwyndham@tds.net